Old Fashioned Egg Salad Recipe

There's something undeniably comforting about a bowl of old fashioned egg salad—simple, creamy, and loaded with nostalgic charm. Whether you’re scooping it onto buttery white bread, piling it high on crackers, or enjoying it straight from the bowl, this timeless dish always hits the spot.

I first started making this egg salad the way my grandma did—no fancy add-ins, just classic ingredients done right. It's the perfect make-ahead lunch that’s quick, affordable, and incredibly satisfying.

With just a handful of pantry staples and a few hard-boiled eggs, you’re just minutes away from a creamy, tangy, and oh-so-delicious egg salad. Let’s dig in.

Why You’ll Love This Old Fashioned Egg Salad

Get ready to rediscover a lunchbox classic that never goes out of style. This old fashioned egg salad is everything you love about homey, simple food—with a flavor that keeps you coming back for more.

First off, it’s wonderfully quick and easy to make. With a batch of hard-boiled eggs ready to go, you can whip this up in under 10 minutes. No cooking, no fuss—just stir and serve.

It’s also budget-friendly. Made with affordable staples like eggs, mayo, and mustard, this recipe feeds a crowd without breaking the bank. It’s one of the cheapest ways to make lunch or snacks for the week.

Another big plus? It’s meal-prep friendly. This egg salad stores beautifully in the fridge, making it ideal for packed lunches, quick bites between meetings, or even a lazy Sunday sandwich.

Finally, this recipe is highly customizable. Like it chunkier or creamier? Want to add a little crunch or spice? You can easily tweak it to suit your tastes or whatever you have on hand.

Whether you’re making sandwiches for the family or prepping lunches for the week, this classic recipe is a tried-and-true favorite that never disappoints.

Ingredients Notes

The charm of this old fashioned egg salad is in its simplicity. Each ingredient plays a key role in creating that creamy, tangy, slightly savory flavor that makes this dish so crave-worthy.

Let’s start with the eggs—the heart of the recipe. You’ll want them hard-boiled and chilled for the best texture. For easier peeling, I recommend older eggs and an ice bath right after boiling. Dice them into chunks for a more rustic texture or mash them for a smoother blend.

Next comes the mayonnaise. This is what gives the salad its creamy body. Use full-fat mayo for the richest flavor, but if you’re looking for a lighter version, a good-quality olive oil mayo or even Greek yogurt can work as substitutes.

A splash of yellow mustard brings just the right amount of tang and brightness. It's that zingy touch that balances the richness of the eggs and mayo. Some people like Dijon for a little more bite—either way works beautifully.

Celery adds a welcome crunch and fresh contrast to the creamy base. Dice it finely so it doesn’t overpower the texture. It’s optional, but I love the little burst of crispness it brings to each bite.

For seasoning, a simple blend of salt, black pepper, and a pinch of paprika is all you need. If you like a little extra zip, a dash of garlic powder or a spoonful of sweet relish can add a fun twist.

No special equipment is needed here—just a saucepan to boil the eggs, a sharp knife, and a mixing bowl. If you want an ultra-smooth egg salad, a pastry cutter or potato masher can come in handy.

How To Make This Old Fashioned Egg Salad

This recipe couldn’t be simpler, but there are a few small tips that can take it from good to truly great. Let’s walk through the process.

Start by boiling your eggs. Place them in a saucepan, cover with cold water, and bring to a boil over medium-high heat. Once the water reaches a rolling boil, remove the pan from heat, cover, and let the eggs sit for 10-12 minutes. Then plunge them into an ice bath to stop the cooking and make peeling easier.

Once your eggs are cooled and peeled, dice or mash them according to your preferred texture. I like a mix of chunks and mashed bits for that classic old-school feel.

In a medium bowl, combine the eggs with mayonnaise and mustard. Start with a couple tablespoons of mayo and a teaspoon of mustard, then adjust to taste. Mix until everything is evenly coated but not overly wet.

Add in your celery and seasoning—a pinch of salt, a few cracks of black pepper, and a tiny dusting of paprika. Stir gently to combine, tasting and adjusting the seasoning as needed.

If you have time, let the salad chill in the fridge for 15–30 minutes before serving. This gives the flavors time to mingle and makes the salad extra refreshing.

All in all, you’re looking at about 20 minutes total—even less if your eggs are already boiled. It’s the kind of recipe you can throw together on a whim and still impress.

Storage Options

One of the best things about egg salad is how well it keeps. Whether you’re meal prepping or saving leftovers, proper storage ensures you can enjoy it for days.

Store your egg salad in an airtight container in the refrigerator. It will stay fresh for up to 3-4 days, though it's best eaten within the first two for peak texture and flavor.

If you notice any liquid separation after sitting, just give it a quick stir before serving. That’s totally normal with mayo-based salads.

Avoid freezing egg salad, as the texture of the eggs and mayo can change dramatically once thawed. It’s best made fresh and eaten within a few days.

To re-serve, scoop it straight onto your favorite bread, wrap, or lettuce cups—or enjoy it with crackers for a quick, protein-packed snack.

Variations and Substitutions

Part of what makes this recipe so lovable is how easy it is to tweak. Whether you're switching things up based on dietary needs or personal taste, there's plenty of room for creativity.

Want a healthier version? Swap the mayo with Greek yogurt or use half-and-half for a lighter, tangier twist. Just keep in mind it won’t be quite as rich.

Add-ins like sweet pickle relish or diced red onion can enhance the flavor with a bit of sweetness and crunch. A little goes a long way, so start small and adjust to your liking.

For a spicy kick, mix in a touch of hot sauce, a pinch of cayenne pepper, or even some diced jalapeños. It adds depth and a nice contrast to the creamy base.

If you're not a fan of celery, try swapping it with diced cucumber, green bell pepper, or even grated carrot for a different kind of crunch.

And of course, herbs like fresh dill, parsley, or chives can bring a bright, garden-fresh flavor that complements the richness beautifully.

The best part about making this classic dish at home? You can make it exactly the way you like it. Don’t be afraid to experiment—you might just land on your new signature egg salad.

Print